| 2022 | Tait | The Manger Mule |
| 2021 | Sweeney | Choquito |
| 2020 | Sweeney | Go Bananas! |
| 2019 | Christensen | A Nog Which Will Live in Infamy! |
| 2018 | Sweeney | S’mores |
| 2017 | Sweeney | Mounds/Almond Joy |
| 2016 | Karau | Eggnoguration |
| 2015 | Chickerson Farms | Barrel-Aged Nog |
| – | – | – |
| 2012 | Karau | Bacon & Eggnog |
| 2011 | Gautier | Amazing Nog |
| 2010 | Sweeney | Spicy Gingerbread |
| 2009 | Hemsell | Cinna-Nog |
| 2008 | Arnott | Creamsicle |
| 2007 | Sweeney | Choc-Ful-O-Orange |
| 2006 | Gautier | Baltimore Nog |
| 2005 | Hemsell | B&S Nog |
| 2004 | Sweeney | The Best Damn Eggnog |
| 2003 | Sweeney | The Best Damn Eggnog |
| 2002 | Karau | Aunt Bean’s Nog |
| 2001 | Hickerson | i-Nog |
| 2000 | Flynn | Three Bowl Eggnog |
| 1999 | Flynn | Three Bowl Eggnog |
